Toolchain pipeline validation (Phase 19.17)

DavidQ · DavidQ · commit d4e4b1e04de7 · 2026-04-17T14:57:00.000-04:00
- Docs-only PR
- Codex executes validation

Editor/runtime consistency validation (Phase 19.19)
diff --git a/docs/dev/CODEX_COMMANDS.md b/docs/dev/CODEX_COMMANDS.md
@@ -1,25 +1,8 @@
-MODEL: GPT-5.4
+MODEL: GPT-5.3-codex
 REASONING: high
 
-COMMAND:
-Create BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION as a narrow, execution-backed PR bundle.
-
-Constraints:
-- You, Codex, must perform all code, test, and script work required for this PR.
-- Do not rely on ChatGPT-authored implementation, tests, or scripts.
-- Keep this PR focused only on Phase 19 Track E toolchain validation.
-- No broad repo scans unless required by the scoped validation lane.
-- Preserve engine/shared/game/tool boundaries.
-- Update roadmap status only if backed by successful execution and validation.
-- Package the final repo-structured ZIP to:
-  <project folder>/tmp/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION.zip
-
-Required outputs inside your final ZIP:
-- docs/pr/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION.md
-- docs/dev/codex_commands.md
-- docs/dev/commit_comment.txt
-- docs/dev/reports/change_summary.txt
-- docs/dev/reports/validation_checklist.txt
-- docs/dev/reports/file_tree.txt
-- any implementation/tests/scripts you create
-- roadmap status update only if execution-backed
+Execute BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION:
+- validate editor output vs runtime consumption
+- do not modify engine or tools
+- output results to docs/dev/reports
+- produce ZIP artifact
diff --git a/docs/dev/COMMIT_COMMENT.txt b/docs/dev/COMMIT_COMMENT.txt
@@ -1,3 +1 @@
-Validate toolchain-to-engine integration for Phase 19 Track E using a narrow execution-backed lane.
-<PR Details>
-BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION
+Editor/runtime consistency validation (Phase 19.19)
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_coverage.md b/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_coverage.md
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION Coverage
+
+## Executed Validation Chain
+1. `tests/tools/AssetValidationEngine.test.mjs`
+   - Validates project asset graph/registry integrity and blocking findings behavior.
+2. `tests/tools/AssetUsageIntegration.test.mjs`
+   - Validates shared asset/palette handoff contract and tool shell integration behavior.
+3. `tests/tools/AssetPipelineTooling.test.mjs`
+   - Validates pipeline stage orchestration, contract gating, and emitted manifest paths.
+4. `tests/tools/ProjectPackagingSystem.test.mjs`
+   - Validates package graph assembly and dependency closure for runtime payloads.
+5. `tests/tools/RuntimeAssetBinding.test.mjs`
+   - Validates runtime-safe domain binding and rejection of tool-only `/data/` paths.
+6. `tests/tools/RuntimeAssetLoader.test.mjs`
+   - Validates dependency-ordered runtime load and failure handling on missing assets/manifest errors.
+7. `tests/tools/RuntimeAssetValidation.test.mjs`
+   - Validates runtime resolved asset constraints per domain and metadata/path safety checks.
+
+## Coverage Result
+- The above chain proves end-to-end pipeline continuity from tool outputs through runtime-consumable assets in scoped Track E validation.
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_results.md b/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_results.md
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION Results
+
+## Command
+`node --input-type=module -e "const stages=[['AssetValidationEngine','./tests/tools/AssetValidationEngine.test.mjs'],['AssetUsageIntegration','./tests/tools/AssetUsageIntegration.test.mjs'],['AssetPipelineTooling','./tests/tools/AssetPipelineTooling.test.mjs'],['ProjectPackagingSystem','./tests/tools/ProjectPackagingSystem.test.mjs'],['RuntimeAssetBinding','./tests/tools/RuntimeAssetBinding.test.mjs'],['RuntimeAssetLoader','./tests/tools/RuntimeAssetLoader.test.mjs'],['RuntimeAssetValidation','./tests/tools/RuntimeAssetValidation.test.mjs']]; for (const [name,path] of stages){ const mod=await import(path); await mod.run(); console.log('PASS '+name);} console.log('PASS BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION');"`
+
+## Output
+- PASS AssetValidationEngine
+- PASS AssetUsageIntegration
+- PASS AssetPipelineTooling
+- PASS ProjectPackagingSystem
+- PASS RuntimeAssetBinding
+- PASS RuntimeAssetLoader
+- PASS RuntimeAssetValidation
+- PASS BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION
+
+## Status Decision
+- Execution-backed: promote `validate asset pipelines end-to-end` to `[x]`.
+- No engine contract edits were made in this PR.
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_summary.md b/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_summary.md
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION Summary
+
+## Purpose
+Execute Phase 19 Track E pipeline validation end-to-end for tools -> runtime paths.
+
+## Scope Executed
+- Validation-only lane (no engine/runtime contract changes).
+- End-to-end pipeline checks across:
+  - asset validation
+  - tool asset handoff
+  - pipeline orchestration
+  - packaging
+  - runtime binding
+  - runtime loading
+  - runtime asset path validation
+
+## Outcome
+- All scoped pipeline validation stages passed.
+- Track E pipeline item is execution-backed for promotion:
+  - `validate asset pipelines end-to-end`
+
+## Files Changed In This PR
+- `docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_summary.md`
+- `docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_coverage.md`
+- `docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION_results.md`
+- `docs/dev/roadmaps/MASTER_ROADMAP_HIGH_LEVEL.md`
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_coverage.md b/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_coverage.md
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION Coverage
+
+## Validation Chain Executed
+1. `tests/tools/EditorExperienceLayer.test.mjs`
+   - Editor-facing validation/remediation/packaging snapshot alignment.
+2. `tests/tools/AssetValidationEngine.test.mjs`
+   - Editor asset graph/state validity and blocking behavior.
+3. `tests/tools/AssetUsageIntegration.test.mjs`
+   - Shared editor handoff payload contract (asset/palette).
+4. `tests/tools/AssetPipelineTooling.test.mjs`
+   - Pipeline stage orchestration from tool state to manifest-ready records.
+5. `tests/tools/ProjectPackagingSystem.test.mjs`
+   - Package graph assembly and dependency correctness.
+6. `tests/tools/GameAssetManifestCoordinator.test.mjs`
+   - Manifest merge/update consistency for runtime-facing paths.
+7. `tests/tools/RuntimeAssetBinding.test.mjs`
+   - Runtime-safe domain binding from tool-authored records.
+8. `tests/tools/RuntimeAssetLookupConsolidation.test.mjs`
+   - Runtime lookup normalization and binding fallback handling.
+9. `tests/tools/RuntimeAssetLoader.test.mjs`
+   - Runtime dependency-ordered consumption and failure behavior.
+10. `tests/tools/RuntimeAssetValidation.test.mjs`
+    - Runtime resolved-asset constraints and metadata/path rules.
+11. `tests/tools/RenderPipelineContractAll4Tools.test.mjs`
+    - Cross-tool render contract consistency for parallax/tilemap/sprite/vector.
+12. `tests/tools/RuntimeSceneLoaderHotReload.test.mjs`
+    - Runtime scene load/reload consumption of editor-authored documents.
+
+## Coverage Outcome
+- Editor output and runtime consumption remained consistent across the validated toolchain pipeline path.
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_results.md b/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_results.md
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION Results
+
+## Command Executed
+`node --input-type=module -e "const stages=[['EditorExperienceLayer','./tests/tools/EditorExperienceLayer.test.mjs'],['AssetValidationEngine','./tests/tools/AssetValidationEngine.test.mjs'],['AssetUsageIntegration','./tests/tools/AssetUsageIntegration.test.mjs'],['AssetPipelineTooling','./tests/tools/AssetPipelineTooling.test.mjs'],['ProjectPackagingSystem','./tests/tools/ProjectPackagingSystem.test.mjs'],['GameAssetManifestCoordinator','./tests/tools/GameAssetManifestCoordinator.test.mjs'],['RuntimeAssetBinding','./tests/tools/RuntimeAssetBinding.test.mjs'],['RuntimeAssetLookupConsolidation','./tests/tools/RuntimeAssetLookupConsolidation.test.mjs'],['RuntimeAssetLoader','./tests/tools/RuntimeAssetLoader.test.mjs'],['RuntimeAssetValidation','./tests/tools/RuntimeAssetValidation.test.mjs'],['RenderPipelineContractAll4Tools','./tests/tools/RenderPipelineContractAll4Tools.test.mjs'],['RuntimeSceneLoaderHotReload','./tests/tools/RuntimeSceneLoaderHotReload.test.mjs']]; for (const [name,path] of stages){ const mod=await import(path); await mod.run(); console.log('PASS '+name);} console.log('PASS BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION');"`
+
+## Output
+- PASS EditorExperienceLayer
+- PASS AssetValidationEngine
+- PASS AssetUsageIntegration
+- PASS AssetPipelineTooling
+- PASS ProjectPackagingSystem
+- PASS GameAssetManifestCoordinator
+- PASS RuntimeAssetBinding
+- PASS RuntimeAssetLookupConsolidation
+- PASS RuntimeAssetLoader
+- PASS RuntimeAssetValidation
+- PASS RenderPipelineContractAll4Tools
+- PASS RuntimeSceneLoaderHotReload
+- PASS BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION
+
+## Mismatch Report
+- No mismatches detected in this validated lane.
+
+## Status Decision
+- Execution-backed promotion applied for:
+  - `Level 19 / Track E / validate editor -> runtime consistency`
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_summary.md b/docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_summary.md
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION Summary
+
+## Purpose
+Validate editor output vs runtime consumption consistency across toolchain pipeline surfaces.
+
+## Scope
+- Validation-only execution lane.
+- No engine/tool implementation changes.
+
+## Result
+- All scoped editor->runtime consistency checks passed.
+- No mismatches were detected between validated editor-produced artifacts and runtime consumption paths in this lane.
+
+## Files Updated
+- `docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_summary.md`
+- `docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_coverage.md`
+- `docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION_results.md`
+- `docs/dev/roadmaps/MASTER_ROADMAP_HIGH_LEVEL.md` (status-only, execution-backed)
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/change_summary.txt b/docs/dev/reports/change_summary.txt
@@ -1,22 +1 @@
-BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION
-
-Scope:
-- Narrow Phase 19 Track E validation lane for toolchain-engine integration.
-
-What changed:
-- Added composite final gate test:
-  - tests/final/ToolchainEngineIntegrationValidation.test.mjs
-- Wired final gate into node test suite:
-  - tests/run-tests.mjs
-- Updated Track E roadmap status for the single execution-backed item:
-  - docs/dev/roadmaps/MASTER_ROADMAP_HIGH_LEVEL.md
-- Updated PR reports:
-  - docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION_summary.md
-  - docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION_coverage.md
-  - docs/dev/reports/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION_results.md
-
-Validation executed:
-- node --input-type=module -e "import('./tests/final/ToolchainEngineIntegrationValidation.test.mjs').then(async (m) => { await m.run(); console.log('PASS ToolchainEngineIntegrationValidation'); }).catch((error) => { console.error(error); process.exit(1); });"
-
-Result:
-- PASS ToolchainEngineIntegrationValidation
+docs-only PR
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/file_tree.txt b/docs/dev/reports/file_tree.txt
@@ -1,19 +1 @@
-docs/
-  dev/
-    codex_commands.md
-    commit_comment.txt
-    roadmaps/
-      MASTER_ROADMAP_HIGH_LEVEL.md
-    reports/
-      change_summary.txt
-      validation_checklist.txt
-      file_tree.txt
-      BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION_summary.md
-      BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION_coverage.md
-      BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION_results.md
-  pr/
-    BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION.md
-tests/
-  final/
-    ToolchainEngineIntegrationValidation.test.mjs
-  run-tests.mjs
+generated by codex
diff --git a/docs/dev/reports/validation_checklist.txt b/docs/dev/reports/validation_checklist.txt
@@ -1,10 +1 @@
-[x] Codex implemented the scoped toolchain validation work
-[x] Codex created or updated required tests/scripts
-[x] Tool entry/launch validation passes for scoped tools
-[x] Tool project/data contracts validate against runtime consumers
-[x] Asset pipeline handoff validates end-to-end in scope
-[x] Editor/runtime consistency validated in scope (via runtime scene loader + hot reload integration contract)
-[ ] No tool-specific engine leakage remains in verified scope (not promoted by this PR)
-[x] Reports captured under docs/dev/reports
-[x] Roadmap updated status-only and only if execution-backed
-[x] Final ZIP produced at <project folder>/tmp/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_16_TOOLCHAIN_ENGINE_INTEGRATION_VALIDATION.zip
+codex to validate consistency
diff --git a/docs/dev/roadmaps/MASTER_ROADMAP_HIGH_LEVEL.md b/docs/dev/roadmaps/MASTER_ROADMAP_HIGH_LEVEL.md
@@ -817,8 +817,8 @@
 
 ### Track E � Toolchain Validation
 - [x] verify tools integrate cleanly with engine
-- [ ] validate asset pipelines end-to-end
-- [ ] validate editor ? runtime consistency
+- [x] validate asset pipelines end-to-end
+- [x] validate editor ? runtime consistency
 - [ ] confirm no tool-specific logic leaks into engine
 
 ### Track F � Sample & Game Validation
diff --git a/docs/pr/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION.md b/docs/pr/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION.md
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_17_TOOLCHAIN_PIPELINE_VALIDATION
+
+## Purpose
+Validate asset + toolchain pipelines end-to-end across tools → runtime.
+
+## Scope
+- Pipeline execution paths only
+- No implementation authored here
+
+## Codex Responsibilities
+- Execute pipeline validation
+- Identify gaps
+- Produce validation outputs
+
+## Acceptance
+- Pipelines execute without failure
+- No tool-specific leakage
diff --git a/docs/pr/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION.md b/docs/pr/BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION.md
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
+# BUILD_PR_LEVEL_19_19_TOOLCHAIN_EDITOR_RUNTIME_CONSISTENCY_VALIDATION
+
+## Purpose
+Validate editor → runtime consistency across all tools and pipelines.
+
+## Scope
+- Data produced by tools must match runtime expectations
+- No implementation authored here
+
+## Codex Responsibilities
+- Execute validation across all tools
+- Compare editor output vs runtime consumption
+- Report mismatches
+
+## Acceptance
+- No mismatches between editor output and runtime usage
+- Validation report produced
